"Liberals in Italy? Divided on elections, secularism, economy, and even Israel
Per alcuni anni, a partire dai risultati delle elezioni del 2004 per il rinnovo del Parlamento Europeo, sono stato assiduamente in contatto con quasi tutti i gruppi e le associazioni dichiaratamente liberali esistenti in Italia, per verificare se esistessero le condizioni minime per una riunificazione, se non di tutti, di una parte significativa dei liberali su una linea politica che ora, per sbrigarmi, call "centrist." That is aimed at overcoming a political system with various tricks, techniques of electoral and institutional rules, many wanted to simplify to the extreme, resolving the dialectic between two parties only. Among the many who, without being enrolled among the laudator Mr Berlusconi, are pleased to be called liberals, for sensitivity developed through specific readings, or family traditions, or for a variety of reasons, I found - almost to the spirit of scientific research - everything and its opposite.
Concerning the electoral law, I have met people who believe the proportion is to be avoided like the plague ("cursed proportional" ha scritto qualcuno) e che non esistano alternative al sistema maggioritario, realizzato attraverso collegi uninominali ad un solo turno. A questi anglofili, il leader dei liberal-democratici britannici, Nick Clegg, recentemente ha dato un dispiacere proponendo di rimettere in discussione con apposito referendum il mantenimento della legge elettorale del Regno Unito, che i nostri pensavano perfetta.
Non mancano, sul fronte opposto, i difensori della proporzionale, che magari vorrebbero purissima, senza alcuno sbarramento, in modo che anche liste che raccolgono lo zero virgola qualcosa abbiano speranze.
Per quanto mi riguarda, so che la legge elettorale perfetta non esiste; personalmente, propendo per un sistema elettorale misto, con la parte prevalente of seats allocated in single-member constituencies, but with candidates in a previous round of compulsory primary and governed by the law, and with a proportion of seats allocated by proportional method among competing lists in districts large enough so as to safeguard pluralism in the composition of Parliament , but not guaranteed by pure majority system, because it might appear that in all the colleges will always prevail the same deployment, in many cases a narrow margin of difference.
But the confusion of tongues (and brain) can be seen with reference to any other topic. So, on one side are the proponents of unity against the threat of lay clergy, on the other there are those argue that being "secular" is not enough to characterize a policy (for example, both John Gentile, as Antonio Gramsci, positions had not confused with that of obedience to the Catholic Church, but it was still a lot of different positions and far between them). Personally, I have deep respect for religious feelings and I am convinced that the value of freedom should be appreciated (especially) in the spiritual dimension, as a process of constant refinement of individual moral conscience and to seek the truth.
To go to the "centrality" of the economy, we find people who believe that everything that is public should be rejected as a source of waste and that the destiny of every cosa vadano decise dal mercato. Si dicono liberali, ma io li definisco anarco-capitalisti. Personalmente, non li sopporto; mi attesto sulla distinzione fra liberismo economico e liberalismo filosofico-politico-giuridico, che fu teorizzata da Benedetto Croce.
Non dimentico mai che politici della Destra storica, come Minghetti e Silvio Spaventa, volevano che il sistema ferroviario nazionale fosse di proprietà e sotto l'esercizio dello Stato; per questo furono messi in minoranza nel 1876 da un'alleanza parlamentare fra Sinistra e liberisti. Così come non dimentico che un economista liberista, quale Ernesto Rossi, fu convinto fautore della nazionalizzazione dell'energia elettrica. In entrambi i casi (ferrovie ed energia elettrica), non per scelte ideological bias, but a realistic assessment of the solution in the given circumstances, it seemed better achieve the public interest.
So far I had deluded that there was any harmony of views among liberals at least limited to major foreign policy decisions. But here are belied by the facts. I discovered a group, obviously liberal, which sends a letter to the Italian foreign minister (no sense of limits) to ask him to withdraw our ambassador in Israel, followed by a vibrant protest the plight of the Palestinians in Gaza and against the Israeli government, whose hands are dripping with blood.
In this regard, I agree wholeheartedly Angelo Panebianco excellent editorial in the Corriere della Sera on June 4, 2010, titled "The fragility of Israel." The present rulers of Israel have made and continue to make serious mistakes, but the context is objectively difficult. Recently it has been made more complicated by the new positions taken by Turkey, which aims to make the Europeans pay the difficulties which have so far hindered by the entrance of that important country in the European Union. A Turkey protagonist of an aggressive foreign policy characterized the Islamic Unity can completely restore equilibrium in the game already very precarious.
I do not want to discuss what were the political orientations of individuals from various backgrounds who have sought to force the Israeli naval blockade to bring aid to the people of Gaza. From a strictly methodological, I ask: is it not true that our world would be even more violent and chaotic take root if the policy that those who do not share a political and military measures (such as the naval blockade, in this case) are entitled to disown it in the name of greater feelings of peace and humanity? It must always be very cautious before venturing into foreign policy considerations, but, thinking in the abstract, China protesters in other countries would tolerate that, in China, organized a protest in favor of Tibet? The Russia would tolerate in its territory, demonstrations for the independence of Chechnya? The violence of a state against those who express opinions always leads to rejection reactions. But we must be clear that not only the Israelis to do so. World history is full of atrocities committed by all States to pursue their goals of power. Even the "civilians" very little English have many pages in their glorious history, to the point of waging war to the Chinese because they refused to continue trading opium. To come to our Italian history, just remember the way the fascist regime normalized Cyrenaica, deporting unarmed people in concentration camps and making it literally dying of hunger and hardship. Until the hanging of Omar al-Mukhtar. The State
Israel had no peace since its inception. In May 1948 he was attacked simultaneously by the following Arab states who had not accepted the del'ONU resolution of 29 November 1947: Egypt, Syria, Lebanon, Transjordan (now Jordan), Iraq and Saudi Arabia. In 1967 (the Six Day War), Israel was to take the initiative in war, but after Nasser had established a ban on Israeli ships to pass through the Suez Canal. The Yom Kippur War was a treacherous attack by Egypt and Syria against Israel. She was chosen for a Jewish religious party by surprise and unprepared for the Israelis. Del'ONU The Security Council did not condemn the attack immediately, but voted for a cease-fire only sixteen days after they had started the hostilities (October 22, 1973) and, of course, gave the wrong Israelis, having suffered the enemy offensive in the first week, had regained the upper hand militarily.
The UN, as it is structured, it gives always wrong to Israel. Representing a small minority worldwide, compared to the numbers and geo-strategic importance of all the Arab and Muslim states. Even the most moderate Arabs, the chips are down, they can not do otherwise than to remain at a range of inter-Arab solidarity.
Israel could survive so far because, in the decisive moments, the U.S. has vetoed resolutions against anti-Israeli UN Security Council. Lo Stato d'Israele sembra forte contro i Palestinesi; ma, in realtà, è potenzialmente sempre più debole contro tutto il mondo arabo e islamico coalizzato. Quando gli Stati Uniti non avranno più la forza politico-militare di sostenere lo Stato d'Israele, questo sarà cancellato dalla carta geografica. Io temo questo esito e certamente non lo auspico. Mi piacerebbe che le prese di posizione pubbliche di quanti si definiscono liberali fossero qualitativamente diverse da quelle di coloro che abitualmente indossano sciarpe e mantelle con i colori palestinesi. Mi piacerebbe che un più sviluppato senso critico facesse comprendere che il male del mondo non inizia e non finisce con lo Stato d'Israele. Arrivo a sperare che Paesi realmente amici di Israele possano play a credible and specific role of mediation in order to induce the same Israeli government to make self-criticism and to follow more prudent policy of seeking peace with those who can - within the diverse Arab and Islamic world - really wants peace.
And, anyway, enough with the "liberal" generic. Go to the dogs. If I had a lesser sense of the ridiculous would propose the formation of a new political breed: the "liberal friends of the common good." Acronym ABC, why all'abbicci policy should go.
LIVIO GHERSI
Friday, June 4, 2010
Thursday, May 27, 2010
Sour Stomach Black Stools
Nocera (Fish): "If confirmed, the block support unconstitutional and therefore very serious "
ROME. "If it were confirmed, the block of support would be unconstitutional so serious." So Salvatore Nocera, vice president of the Fish ( Italian Federation to overcome handicaps ) commented that the economic measures last night received the first green light by the Council of Ministers. In the anti-crisis package, in fact, checked a provision that staffing of support teachers for the 2010/2011 school year should remain unchanged from the previous year , in fact undermining the ruling of the Constitutional Court n . 80 of this year which had declared unlawful any the roof support posts.
"Minister Gelmini told the press that the school would not be touched. It is not clear what happens. We will try to verify what the actual situation, but if there is, the freezing of support teachers is a palese violazione di una norma costituzionale " da parte del governo, "e questo è un fatto gravissimo", ha detto Nocera. Anche perché "l'unica strada possibile" per fermare la manovra di Tremonti "è un nuovo ricorso alla Consulta". Ma ciò significherebbe "far passare ancora un altro anno", ha concluso il vicepresidente della Fish.
Dati alla mano, se tutto restasse come oggi, la circolare n. 37 del 13 aprile 2010 emessa dal ministero dell'Istruzione (e quindi precedente al pacchetto anti-crisi) prevede "una riduzione del personale docente di 25.600 posti per l'anno 2010/2011 (22 mila in organico di diritto e 3.600 in organico di fatto e di cui oltre 3.000 in Campania e Sicilia) e 90.469 Total support posts, which employs 63,348 in 27,121 in the organic law and of fact, "the report said. But support teachers announced for the next school year are roughly the same number 2009/2010: increases so the Organic Law (4885 teachers in more) but then set the de facto organic.
(from pressin.comune.venezia.it )
The budget seeks to circumvent the Constitutional Court ruling that established the unconstitutionality of the "ceiling" of hours for support for pupils diversamenteabili.
Salvatore Nocera's commentary.
"Minister Gelmini told the press that the school would not be touched. It is not clear what happens. We will try to verify what the actual situation, but if there is, the freezing of support teachers is a palese violazione di una norma costituzionale " da parte del governo, "e questo è un fatto gravissimo", ha detto Nocera. Anche perché "l'unica strada possibile" per fermare la manovra di Tremonti "è un nuovo ricorso alla Consulta". Ma ciò significherebbe "far passare ancora un altro anno", ha concluso il vicepresidente della Fish.
Dati alla mano, se tutto restasse come oggi, la circolare n. 37 del 13 aprile 2010 emessa dal ministero dell'Istruzione (e quindi precedente al pacchetto anti-crisi) prevede "una riduzione del personale docente di 25.600 posti per l'anno 2010/2011 (22 mila in organico di diritto e 3.600 in organico di fatto e di cui oltre 3.000 in Campania e Sicilia) e 90.469 Total support posts, which employs 63,348 in 27,121 in the organic law and of fact, "the report said. But support teachers announced for the next school year are roughly the same number 2009/2010: increases so the Organic Law (4885 teachers in more) but then set the de facto organic.
(from pressin.comune.venezia.it )
Monday, May 10, 2010
Christina Aguilera,boobs
strike ballots, Cobas: hymn to the CGIL blackleggery
(AGI News)
Dry replica of the Cobas national spokesperson, Piero Bernocchi, the letter general secretary of the FLC-CGIL, Domenico Pantaleo, sent to the local structures of his organization to to distance themselves from the strike of the ballots in June against the cuts implemented by the government in the school division: "in the letter - explains Bernocchi - is a frontal attack, almost a 'hymn to the strike-breaking' , a form of struggle, with considerable commitment and effort, we are organizing, in close collaboration with the movement of temporary workers this year has been the vanguard of the struggle in defense of the public school .
Cobas spokesman claims that the position of the CGIL leader of knowledge workers is not shared by all of its union "during the national congress Flc - Bernocchi points - despite many delegates call upon the participation in the strike of ballots, the mountain gave birth to the 'mouse' of 'the General Assembly of the school' for next autumn, in addition to not being able to be passed off as a serious form of struggle, would come 'father died in' , after cancellation other 41 000 jobs and the expulsion of the precarious .
About the affirmation of Pantaleo, which states that the strike would have little effect because it would at most lead to 'a mere shift of date', says Bernocchi that "five days of moving create a bureaucratic bottleneck no small feat, given that if we prevent school heads to hold illegal elections before the end of the school, such as the time available during final exams before the higher will be very limited, giving the strike even greater visibility. "
(AGI News)
Dry replica of the Cobas national spokesperson, Piero Bernocchi, the letter general secretary of the FLC-CGIL, Domenico Pantaleo, sent to the local structures of his organization to to distance themselves from the strike of the ballots in June against the cuts implemented by the government in the school division: "in the letter - explains Bernocchi - is a frontal attack, almost a 'hymn to the strike-breaking' , a form of struggle, with considerable commitment and effort, we are organizing, in close collaboration with the movement of temporary workers this year has been the vanguard of the struggle in defense of the public school .
Cobas spokesman claims that the position of the CGIL leader of knowledge workers is not shared by all of its union "during the national congress Flc - Bernocchi points - despite many delegates call upon the participation in the strike of ballots, the mountain gave birth to the 'mouse' of 'the General Assembly of the school' for next autumn, in addition to not being able to be passed off as a serious form of struggle, would come 'father died in' , after cancellation other 41 000 jobs and the expulsion of the precarious .
About the affirmation of Pantaleo, which states that the strike would have little effect because it would at most lead to 'a mere shift of date', says Bernocchi that "five days of moving create a bureaucratic bottleneck no small feat, given that if we prevent school heads to hold illegal elections before the end of the school, such as the time available during final exams before the higher will be very limited, giving the strike even greater visibility. "
Monday, May 3, 2010
Font Similar To Jersey Font
panel and the panel: big ideas, imagination, genius and great political mistakes
not only the Radicals have 55 years, and so are the oldest party in Italian business e con rappresentanti eletti, ma il fondatore Marco Pannella ha compiuto ieri 80 anni, e dunque è il più vecchio leader politico attivo in Italia. E noi che siamo liberali e anche radicali dalla prima adolescenza, sia pure in dissenso su alcuni punti, auguriamo a Marco, ai Radicali e all’Italia ancora tanti anni di coraggiose battaglie per la libertà, la giustizia e i diritti civili.
Pannella è non solo un grande uomo dalla forte personalità, ma ormai – per la sua continuativa presenza vigile e critica a partire dal dopoguerra – quasi un nuovo "Padre della Patria" dell’Italia contemporanea, un continuatore eccentrico ma onesto della cultura dei Cavour, dei Pannunzio, degli Ernesto Rossi e dei Salvemini, and therefore Italy, who got even less than they have ever loved, is with him still in debt of gratitude.
That little 'liberal reforms in countries with liberal democracy that was already safely in place for decades, Pannella and the handful of radicals we have the dates in a dramatic way, at the price of struggle and great sacrifices, stimulating the coachmen as annoying fly parties and institutions, exposing himself, or stop making process. Only for pathological research of vision? Not only that, even if it is true that in Via di Torre Argentina's residence a real "party newspaper, who lives with his eyes constantly on TV and newspapers, and even the actions e i programmi adatta scientificamente su misura dei vari media. Allora per eroismo o masochismo? Neanche.
Il fatto è che nel nostro Paese le forze reazionarie o conservatrici, la Chiesa in testa, hanno sempre opposto – a differenza che altrove – resistenze durissime alle riforme democratiche e liberali, alla trasparenza, al controllo dei cittadini sugli atti degli eletti, al rispetto delle regole, alla concorrenza, al merito senza raccomandazioni, al riconoscimento dei diritti civili, alla separazione tra Stato e Chiesa. Noi non abbiamo avuto una vera "rivoluzione liberale": ecco perché perfino un Partito Liberale, se ci fosse, dovrebbe essere in Italia più duro e aggressivo che nei Paesi anglosassoni. Ma non c'è.
.
another matter, however, is the opinion on the options on the ideological and political tactics radicals. Pannella, who went away, too soon, the Liberal Party, in which a young man was part of the liberal left, has long believed that there might be the famous "ircocervo" liberal socialist on which he had rightly joked Benedetto Croce. So much so radical that even today is remembered at home with sympathy and compassion "the reform project," lib-lab Craxi, who had a century of delay on any partitucolo liberal.
fact is that the baby Radical Party in 1955 would be the successor of the unfortunate Action Party, a sua volta la realizzazione politica del movimento antifascista Giustizia e Libertà fondato sul binomio Pensiero e Azione. Ma sfuggì ai primi radicali, un po’ per colpa loro e un po’ per il pessimo esempio offerto in quegli anni e nei decenni futuri – con l’unica eccezione della battaglia per il divorzio – da un Partito Liberale Italiano, in realtà ultra-moderato o conservatore, che il Liberalismo non ha certo bisogno del Socialismo per ritrovare in sé il coraggio del Risorgimento, il laicismo, le riforme più avanzate, la solidarietà per i più deboli, la flessibilità in economia. Neanche Keynes, che fu un personaggio-limite, era un socialista. E d’altra parte fu il liberale Zanardelli to create the State Railways. Cavour was to charge more taxes for the wealthy, and even himself. It was Cavour and Siccardi to remove the privileges of the ecclesiastical entities, and to stop even the archbishop of Turin, which instigated the people to disregard the law of the State. Would have sufficed for the self-styled "liberals" really did Italian liberals, modern liberals better.
Today, socialism has now irrevocably lost, and liberalism has swept the competition's history. And, fortunately, thanks to the current global economic crisis, almost not enough texts of liberal writers, he also saw that liberalism does not coincide with some capital, of which the bottom (as well as for state institutions) is limited to being a sponsor, an arbitrator.
Yet, Marco Pannella, is still convinced that the ultimate role of radicals in the "alternative Left", not nell'egemonizzare many liberals. Not by accident, after the bleeding and the defections of radical promoters, Pannunzio to Rossi, the small fraction that remained to manage the historic symbol of the Radicals in the early 60 pannelliana was that of "radical left". Just read the eloquent voice of the long history Radical Party, which few people know.
Then, at least, there was still a small but active and inadequate Liberal Party. Can not understand that Pannella Missing in Italy, the only western country formally "liberal", a strong political entity liberal majority, as befits the ideology that has won with his name and holding the whole shebang the West and even some Eastern European countries? There is a shortage not only of liberalism in Italy, but even liberal political representation. Deficit that certainly the tiny part of the Radicals can not compensate. Also because many liberals deny that radical friends are true liberals.
And then, you need to speak to large majorities of citizens, ordinary people, not just to traditional minorities marginalized (but "privileged" by the Radicals), such as prisoners, drug addicts, the sick, the pro-abortion, homosexuals and so on.
Yet, the "union of minorities" - which even then are electorally gratings, that is not going to vote, because voting is radical then the normal "bourgeois" of the big city with their vote of conscience - and the heroic collecting signatures table at the district, and the constant appeal to the people coll'inflazionato referendum, did not prevent the Radicals to aspire to the Great Institutional Policy. And this is a first contradiction. Not
loved in return (the famous incident of the slap in front of the seat because of the Dark Shops), Pannella claimed to involve not the Liberal Party and the Republican Party, actually insignificant because they represent the spread liberalism in the country, but the Communist Party. Similarly, after the court has provocatively to Craxi's Socialists and now the Democratic Party. This is the target of radical alliances, not the secular-liberal, despite the clichés common in the base of liberal historians.
Therefore, it is long-standing historical mistake of the main panels, the lack of aggregation, through the power of crystallization of his charismatic personality, of all the Italian liberals in a single symbol. Subject that we know a winner, as all opinion polls give the liberal position - with the most appropriate questions on various topics, from secularity of the state economy - 30 to 50 percent approval rating and more than Italians. Are we or are not, after all, or 7.a 8.a industrial power of the West? If the United States or Britain, for example, the questionnaire would give respectively 90 and 70 percent, it would be strange, therefore, that in Italy the "liberal" into a pure ideological meaning they had less than a third.
And if this is true, "Peter", the "collegiate", the 'exhibitionist', the 'narcissistic', the "histrionic" Pannella, all got up a little bit of movement, an elite agitator, The tiger mosquito-isolated and therefore highly visible, but also very easy (for him) from control as opposed to a major party, would have given up a great subject Liberal unit for at least 30 percent of the vote, in short, a great party leader of government?
course panel is not temperamentally a prime minister, but a brilliant spoiler, one that produces health "crisis", not the one consists, a scandal that raises not one that soothes them.
With the aggravating circumstance that the current radical party, "Italian Radicals", although a small group of activists joined together exemplary "for the life and death" and that policy is 24 hours over 24 at the time of the elections lost look busy and take vows of generic ideals and sympathy as any liberal movement, that is becomes a "party of opinion." So I might as well ...
Nah, who thought this show did not know the psychology in general and in particular the character of Pannella. In any large party that respects, namely that he had confronted every day with the dialectic and the system of alliances with other major parties in the government or even an irrepressible extrovert as a panel could no longer make "Peter", or invent in five minutes of its famous, brilliant Mattan, unpredictable even for militants loyal. The playmaker improviser, the provocateur, the first lady, should have put in check, to deal with other leading ladies - and many characters trivial, obscure and mediocre - possibly from the ruling classes of other secular parties, just like that in a liberal who is generally rational and serious, very willing to politics as spectacle, much less noble to "blackmail" of non-violent violence to Gandhi .
is why, from the beginning, Pannella has never been occupied, but Liberals of the Left, even the most extreme, despite its origins and even its overt ideological sympathy for the Great Right Cavour. We say that the multifaceted and complicated Marco ideology has had to bend to politics, and his very special character to this histrionic. An actor of his caliber, instead of Malagodi and La Malfa, would have been unthinkable ridiculous besides.
But today? History is not made with the "if", but the 90's, just to coincide with the crisis of the PRI and PLI, Pannella could and should have found the General Assembly of liberalism, despite his dislike for the ideologies of all time, including the 'ism liberal. His habit of ideological anti-personalistic politics without inhibitions, which biographers kinder call "pragmatism", "syncretism" and "cross" was to sell at least in front of the convenience to use. Those were good times: the end of the Christian Democrats, the Berlin Wall crisis of communist and socialist parties, liberal triumph, economic development, the beginning of globalization, and Berlusconi has not yet descended into politics. Now, then, after the forced migration Capezzone brilliant communicator, he could also be a Young Liberal leader unit is the same panel that condemns the false and without bipolar view, from right to left, with the rise of a cynical politicians and business that is by far the worst in the history of united Italy. And the blatant examples that come from the UK, with Clegg that he can pierce the television screen with liberal ideas and strengthening the UK starting from pole third of the votes, they should convince anyone, but the stubborn Marco.
The Radicals, In short, although they also fill the mouth of the magic word "liberal", are still convinced of the futility of the fatuity of the volatile political weight of the Liberals, especially Italians. Pannella, it is clear, was the black-white photograph of his youth, when the Liberals were really typical gentlemen, distinguished gentlemen and honest intellectuals, sometimes even aristocrats (for letting us today!), But theoretical and somewhat lazy, lost in the its thousand interests of people or very smart or very rich, unable to speak to people or really understand it, denied the psychology of communications for policy change, for propaganda. All "Political secretary" in pectore, but no militant.
And if that was the psycho-sociological imprint received by the young panel and wonder if "his" radical, post-calogeriani are now - in opposition - all action and no thought, short single copy frenetic activism, Copy for the same radical members, for the political class and Italy? An excess of provocative actions, in the noblest sense of the term that has come to create cohesion "heroism," the fanatical sect atmosphere reminiscent of early Christians. And the thirst for "truth", a term very liberal, as well as ahimsha and sathyagraha , comes from the great Capitini, Catholics and non-violent vegetarian inventor of the "peace march", which was one of his teachers, the head of the Protestant Christian from his impatience.
Hurrah, then, Pannella, the sacred monster of Italian politics, the politician par excellence, non-political (but lives and breathes politics 24 hours out of 24), the "different" of chastity, which makes her very vibrant 80 years. Thank you very much for everything you did, stimulated, invented or thought. Italy must be grateful. And a seat in the Senate for life they deserve, certainly, but only if it were not still so active, so provocative, so "young", so intellectually biased.
.
may seem paradoxical that Marco Pannella, now beginning to be painted almost as a "noble father" even by his eternal enemy, just being accused by the Liberals. Not to have done but "not doing" something. He, too, indeed he who had aroused among the most liberal reformists high expectations, has made mistakes, and serious. Pass them in review:
1. Against ideologies, EVEN AGAINST THE ONE THAT WON. The first mistake is to believe that liberalism is not sufficient in itself, and that we should meet with the social (but would be a "ircocervo" Cross was right), or at least with some sort of Christian pietism mold reformer. Pannella is actually the anti-ideologue par excellence: this - is convinced - should allow him to wander at ease and unlimited access to Right and Left as a prima donna, cross everything and everyone. Too easy.
2. THE CHARACTER INSTEAD OF PROGRAMS. The second is that it gave too much space to the character of the character, his improvisations to the media, to obscure his speeches for decades, Sibylline, twisted baroque and incomprehensible, and not to alternative programs and concrete, with a few clear words and simple as it is in Anglo-Saxon tradition and liberal, and especially the long-term goals.
3. THE REVIEW OF marginalized minorities. Instead of ideologies or programs there are a few themes and protected categories: prisoners, drug addicts, abortion, divorziandi, gay, etc.. And the common people, the vast majority of citizens?
4. FORMER MEMBERS OF PARLIAMENT. The third error, to operate in civil society and then seek alliances only in Parliament, where - of course, with the system of "appointed" not elected - the liberals are not, there can be. So why groped to talk to the right and left, and team up with "dogs and pigs"? Machiavellian behavior and newspeak ..
5. NEVER THOUGHT IN THE LIBERAL PARTY. The fourth error, the main one, not understanding now that liberalism is now widespread among the people in Italy is not a great liberal subject, which is unique in the world, and therefore had to hold - but without any control, dominated by the first peer (something very difficult for the Panel) - real its not the States-General of small parties or abbreviations exist, but the nascent liberalism, ubiquitous in the country. Initiative that only Pannella, with the tenacity, the ability to charm and charisma that he could promote.
6. TO BE A STAR Sting. Finally, the error of failing to grasp, while imitating the Anglo-Saxons, in those countries that the action of "liberal" or radical worked on detail or further specialist In short, to "mother-in-law" of liberal governments. But in Italy, where missing, has always lacked, a Great Liberal Party, this action of rival and critical stimulus or can not work with a right and left both illiberal, businessmen, patronage, clerical and anti-democratic, and therefore to our own Radicals would be given (as it always has been entrusted, in fact) a role too ambitious, even surrogate, which is untenable for an elite few hundred activists.
.
IMAGE. Marco Pannella caricature of a successful referendum in Franco Bruna
not only the Radicals have 55 years, and so are the oldest party in Italian business e con rappresentanti eletti, ma il fondatore Marco Pannella ha compiuto ieri 80 anni, e dunque è il più vecchio leader politico attivo in Italia. E noi che siamo liberali e anche radicali dalla prima adolescenza, sia pure in dissenso su alcuni punti, auguriamo a Marco, ai Radicali e all’Italia ancora tanti anni di coraggiose battaglie per la libertà, la giustizia e i diritti civili. Pannella è non solo un grande uomo dalla forte personalità, ma ormai – per la sua continuativa presenza vigile e critica a partire dal dopoguerra – quasi un nuovo "Padre della Patria" dell’Italia contemporanea, un continuatore eccentrico ma onesto della cultura dei Cavour, dei Pannunzio, degli Ernesto Rossi e dei Salvemini, and therefore Italy, who got even less than they have ever loved, is with him still in debt of gratitude.
That little 'liberal reforms in countries with liberal democracy that was already safely in place for decades, Pannella and the handful of radicals we have the dates in a dramatic way, at the price of struggle and great sacrifices, stimulating the coachmen as annoying fly parties and institutions, exposing himself, or stop making process. Only for pathological research of vision? Not only that, even if it is true that in Via di Torre Argentina's residence a real "party newspaper, who lives with his eyes constantly on TV and newspapers, and even the actions e i programmi adatta scientificamente su misura dei vari media. Allora per eroismo o masochismo? Neanche.
Il fatto è che nel nostro Paese le forze reazionarie o conservatrici, la Chiesa in testa, hanno sempre opposto – a differenza che altrove – resistenze durissime alle riforme democratiche e liberali, alla trasparenza, al controllo dei cittadini sugli atti degli eletti, al rispetto delle regole, alla concorrenza, al merito senza raccomandazioni, al riconoscimento dei diritti civili, alla separazione tra Stato e Chiesa. Noi non abbiamo avuto una vera "rivoluzione liberale": ecco perché perfino un Partito Liberale, se ci fosse, dovrebbe essere in Italia più duro e aggressivo che nei Paesi anglosassoni. Ma non c'è.
.
another matter, however, is the opinion on the options on the ideological and political tactics radicals. Pannella, who went away, too soon, the Liberal Party, in which a young man was part of the liberal left, has long believed that there might be the famous "ircocervo" liberal socialist on which he had rightly joked Benedetto Croce. So much so radical that even today is remembered at home with sympathy and compassion "the reform project," lib-lab Craxi, who had a century of delay on any partitucolo liberal.
fact is that the baby Radical Party in 1955 would be the successor of the unfortunate Action Party, a sua volta la realizzazione politica del movimento antifascista Giustizia e Libertà fondato sul binomio Pensiero e Azione. Ma sfuggì ai primi radicali, un po’ per colpa loro e un po’ per il pessimo esempio offerto in quegli anni e nei decenni futuri – con l’unica eccezione della battaglia per il divorzio – da un Partito Liberale Italiano, in realtà ultra-moderato o conservatore, che il Liberalismo non ha certo bisogno del Socialismo per ritrovare in sé il coraggio del Risorgimento, il laicismo, le riforme più avanzate, la solidarietà per i più deboli, la flessibilità in economia. Neanche Keynes, che fu un personaggio-limite, era un socialista. E d’altra parte fu il liberale Zanardelli to create the State Railways. Cavour was to charge more taxes for the wealthy, and even himself. It was Cavour and Siccardi to remove the privileges of the ecclesiastical entities, and to stop even the archbishop of Turin, which instigated the people to disregard the law of the State. Would have sufficed for the self-styled "liberals" really did Italian liberals, modern liberals better.
Today, socialism has now irrevocably lost, and liberalism has swept the competition's history. And, fortunately, thanks to the current global economic crisis, almost not enough texts of liberal writers, he also saw that liberalism does not coincide with some capital, of which the bottom (as well as for state institutions) is limited to being a sponsor, an arbitrator.
Yet, Marco Pannella, is still convinced that the ultimate role of radicals in the "alternative Left", not nell'egemonizzare many liberals. Not by accident, after the bleeding and the defections of radical promoters, Pannunzio to Rossi, the small fraction that remained to manage the historic symbol of the Radicals in the early 60 pannelliana was that of "radical left". Just read the eloquent voice of the long history Radical Party, which few people know.
Then, at least, there was still a small but active and inadequate Liberal Party. Can not understand that Pannella Missing in Italy, the only western country formally "liberal", a strong political entity liberal majority, as befits the ideology that has won with his name and holding the whole shebang the West and even some Eastern European countries? There is a shortage not only of liberalism in Italy, but even liberal political representation. Deficit that certainly the tiny part of the Radicals can not compensate. Also because many liberals deny that radical friends are true liberals.
And then, you need to speak to large majorities of citizens, ordinary people, not just to traditional minorities marginalized (but "privileged" by the Radicals), such as prisoners, drug addicts, the sick, the pro-abortion, homosexuals and so on.
Yet, the "union of minorities" - which even then are electorally gratings, that is not going to vote, because voting is radical then the normal "bourgeois" of the big city with their vote of conscience - and the heroic collecting signatures table at the district, and the constant appeal to the people coll'inflazionato referendum, did not prevent the Radicals to aspire to the Great Institutional Policy. And this is a first contradiction. Not
loved in return (the famous incident of the slap in front of the seat because of the Dark Shops), Pannella claimed to involve not the Liberal Party and the Republican Party, actually insignificant because they represent the spread liberalism in the country, but the Communist Party. Similarly, after the court has provocatively to Craxi's Socialists and now the Democratic Party. This is the target of radical alliances, not the secular-liberal, despite the clichés common in the base of liberal historians.
Therefore, it is long-standing historical mistake of the main panels, the lack of aggregation, through the power of crystallization of his charismatic personality, of all the Italian liberals in a single symbol. Subject that we know a winner, as all opinion polls give the liberal position - with the most appropriate questions on various topics, from secularity of the state economy - 30 to 50 percent approval rating and more than Italians. Are we or are not, after all, or 7.a 8.a industrial power of the West? If the United States or Britain, for example, the questionnaire would give respectively 90 and 70 percent, it would be strange, therefore, that in Italy the "liberal" into a pure ideological meaning they had less than a third.
And if this is true, "Peter", the "collegiate", the 'exhibitionist', the 'narcissistic', the "histrionic" Pannella, all got up a little bit of movement, an elite agitator, The tiger mosquito-isolated and therefore highly visible, but also very easy (for him) from control as opposed to a major party, would have given up a great subject Liberal unit for at least 30 percent of the vote, in short, a great party leader of government?
course panel is not temperamentally a prime minister, but a brilliant spoiler, one that produces health "crisis", not the one consists, a scandal that raises not one that soothes them.
With the aggravating circumstance that the current radical party, "Italian Radicals", although a small group of activists joined together exemplary "for the life and death" and that policy is 24 hours over 24 at the time of the elections lost look busy and take vows of generic ideals and sympathy as any liberal movement, that is becomes a "party of opinion." So I might as well ...
Nah, who thought this show did not know the psychology in general and in particular the character of Pannella. In any large party that respects, namely that he had confronted every day with the dialectic and the system of alliances with other major parties in the government or even an irrepressible extrovert as a panel could no longer make "Peter", or invent in five minutes of its famous, brilliant Mattan, unpredictable even for militants loyal. The playmaker improviser, the provocateur, the first lady, should have put in check, to deal with other leading ladies - and many characters trivial, obscure and mediocre - possibly from the ruling classes of other secular parties, just like that in a liberal who is generally rational and serious, very willing to politics as spectacle, much less noble to "blackmail" of non-violent violence to Gandhi .
is why, from the beginning, Pannella has never been occupied, but Liberals of the Left, even the most extreme, despite its origins and even its overt ideological sympathy for the Great Right Cavour. We say that the multifaceted and complicated Marco ideology has had to bend to politics, and his very special character to this histrionic. An actor of his caliber, instead of Malagodi and La Malfa, would have been unthinkable ridiculous besides.
But today? History is not made with the "if", but the 90's, just to coincide with the crisis of the PRI and PLI, Pannella could and should have found the General Assembly of liberalism, despite his dislike for the ideologies of all time, including the 'ism liberal. His habit of ideological anti-personalistic politics without inhibitions, which biographers kinder call "pragmatism", "syncretism" and "cross" was to sell at least in front of the convenience to use. Those were good times: the end of the Christian Democrats, the Berlin Wall crisis of communist and socialist parties, liberal triumph, economic development, the beginning of globalization, and Berlusconi has not yet descended into politics. Now, then, after the forced migration Capezzone brilliant communicator, he could also be a Young Liberal leader unit is the same panel that condemns the false and without bipolar view, from right to left, with the rise of a cynical politicians and business that is by far the worst in the history of united Italy. And the blatant examples that come from the UK, with Clegg that he can pierce the television screen with liberal ideas and strengthening the UK starting from pole third of the votes, they should convince anyone, but the stubborn Marco.
The Radicals, In short, although they also fill the mouth of the magic word "liberal", are still convinced of the futility of the fatuity of the volatile political weight of the Liberals, especially Italians. Pannella, it is clear, was the black-white photograph of his youth, when the Liberals were really typical gentlemen, distinguished gentlemen and honest intellectuals, sometimes even aristocrats (for letting us today!), But theoretical and somewhat lazy, lost in the its thousand interests of people or very smart or very rich, unable to speak to people or really understand it, denied the psychology of communications for policy change, for propaganda. All "Political secretary" in pectore, but no militant.
And if that was the psycho-sociological imprint received by the young panel and wonder if "his" radical, post-calogeriani are now - in opposition - all action and no thought, short single copy frenetic activism, Copy for the same radical members, for the political class and Italy? An excess of provocative actions, in the noblest sense of the term that has come to create cohesion "heroism," the fanatical sect atmosphere reminiscent of early Christians. And the thirst for "truth", a term very liberal, as well as ahimsha and sathyagraha , comes from the great Capitini, Catholics and non-violent vegetarian inventor of the "peace march", which was one of his teachers, the head of the Protestant Christian from his impatience.
Hurrah, then, Pannella, the sacred monster of Italian politics, the politician par excellence, non-political (but lives and breathes politics 24 hours out of 24), the "different" of chastity, which makes her very vibrant 80 years. Thank you very much for everything you did, stimulated, invented or thought. Italy must be grateful. And a seat in the Senate for life they deserve, certainly, but only if it were not still so active, so provocative, so "young", so intellectually biased.
.
may seem paradoxical that Marco Pannella, now beginning to be painted almost as a "noble father" even by his eternal enemy, just being accused by the Liberals. Not to have done but "not doing" something. He, too, indeed he who had aroused among the most liberal reformists high expectations, has made mistakes, and serious. Pass them in review:
1. Against ideologies, EVEN AGAINST THE ONE THAT WON. The first mistake is to believe that liberalism is not sufficient in itself, and that we should meet with the social (but would be a "ircocervo" Cross was right), or at least with some sort of Christian pietism mold reformer. Pannella is actually the anti-ideologue par excellence: this - is convinced - should allow him to wander at ease and unlimited access to Right and Left as a prima donna, cross everything and everyone. Too easy.
2. THE CHARACTER INSTEAD OF PROGRAMS. The second is that it gave too much space to the character of the character, his improvisations to the media, to obscure his speeches for decades, Sibylline, twisted baroque and incomprehensible, and not to alternative programs and concrete, with a few clear words and simple as it is in Anglo-Saxon tradition and liberal, and especially the long-term goals.
3. THE REVIEW OF marginalized minorities. Instead of ideologies or programs there are a few themes and protected categories: prisoners, drug addicts, abortion, divorziandi, gay, etc.. And the common people, the vast majority of citizens?
4. FORMER MEMBERS OF PARLIAMENT. The third error, to operate in civil society and then seek alliances only in Parliament, where - of course, with the system of "appointed" not elected - the liberals are not, there can be. So why groped to talk to the right and left, and team up with "dogs and pigs"? Machiavellian behavior and newspeak ..
5. NEVER THOUGHT IN THE LIBERAL PARTY. The fourth error, the main one, not understanding now that liberalism is now widespread among the people in Italy is not a great liberal subject, which is unique in the world, and therefore had to hold - but without any control, dominated by the first peer (something very difficult for the Panel) - real its not the States-General of small parties or abbreviations exist, but the nascent liberalism, ubiquitous in the country. Initiative that only Pannella, with the tenacity, the ability to charm and charisma that he could promote.
6. TO BE A STAR Sting. Finally, the error of failing to grasp, while imitating the Anglo-Saxons, in those countries that the action of "liberal" or radical worked on detail or further specialist In short, to "mother-in-law" of liberal governments. But in Italy, where missing, has always lacked, a Great Liberal Party, this action of rival and critical stimulus or can not work with a right and left both illiberal, businessmen, patronage, clerical and anti-democratic, and therefore to our own Radicals would be given (as it always has been entrusted, in fact) a role too ambitious, even surrogate, which is untenable for an elite few hundred activists.
.
IMAGE. Marco Pannella caricature of a successful referendum in Franco Bruna
Subscribe to:
Posts (Atom)